We are pleased to announce a significant victory in a recent court case concerning the application of local water laws to the county’s permitting decisions. For years, MVCC has expressed concerns about the county’s adherence to local water laws and the sustainability of water resources to support growth while maintaining adequate water levels for fish and wildlife, and other uses. In 2022, the county began using a water availability checklist to assess water adequacy in order to approve or deny development proposals. When MVCC requested the document, the county denied public access to the checklist, claiming attorney-client privilege. 

In this important ruling, Court Commissioner Colbert declared the checklist a public document, as it is used in the regular course of the county’s business. This decision marks a crucial win for open and transparent government, and for accountability in our use of limited water resources. MVCC was represented by Paul Lawrence of the Pacifica Law Group.  

“In the face of climate change, the allocation of water resources is of paramount importance, said Tom Jones, board chairman of Methow Valley Citizens Council. “This ruling affirms the public’s right to know how the county is managing these resources.” 

“This is not just a victory for our organization, but for every citizen who values transparency, accountability, and the sustainable use of our water resources.” 

MVCC will continue to advocate for the natural environment and rural character of Okanogan County, ensuring that growth and development are contingent on protection of water, wildlife, open space and other qualities that are consistently valued by local communities.  

MVCC is currently involved in another case against Okanogan County, alongside the statewide organization Futurewise. The organizations appealed the 2021 Comprehensive Plan adopted by county Commissioners on the grounds that it does not adequately protect water resources and farmland. Okanogan County’s argument to dismiss the case was heard in the State Court of Appeals in Spokane in October. A decision in that case is pending. 

You can read the text of the public records case here.